P&C underwriting factors (DMV reports, credit, etc) is not the same as PHI which is protected by federal laws. Unless HIPAA is repealed or amended, you are not going to see the kind of information available to agents that is required to underwrite & issue a policy.
Besides, agents are idiots. They think everything should be covered and every application approved.
Health underwriting is much more complex vs. auto or HO coverage.
Since I've never 'underwritten' a health policy, I'll have to relent that it is more complicated. As far as HIPAA goes, I'm not sure there is a limitation IF, similar to what is done for MVR access, you sign the appropriate paperwork, promise not to share or disclose, etc, etc. It basically would make you a 'junior underwriter', providing access. Now, I admit, I haven't read all of HIPAA laws, I could be way off base, but my guess is it is a convenient excuse, more than reality.
Besides, I write auto policies where the computer sees the MVR, I don't really have to, it simply tells me how to rate it. Now, I do actually pull an MVR and go over it with the client if there is anything worthwhile going over (such as that suspended license status).
Now, as far as agents being lazy buffoons, you got me there. This is of course, why, just as in P&C, the carrier would need a 60 day window to decline, something that doesn't currently exist in health, and I'm not sure if it does in all states on P&C. Of course, in health, they have 2 years, which seems a bit ridiculous!!!!
I just hate the waiting game. More carriers are going to rapid issue anyway, unless there are extenuating circumstances.
Dan