Is There Anything I Can Do About This?

CFP83

Guru
100+ Post Club
Unfortunately my home was broken into TWICE within a 90 day time period late last year.

The first occurence happened between 8 & 10 am, it was discovered by my cleaning lady around 11am, and she immediately called me and the police. I left the office and came to the house to meet the officer and had the report filed. The only two items that were taken were 2 lcd flatscreen tv's, but there was also a decent amount of damage to the back-door of my home which they apparently used a crow-bar to enter. I called my agent who opened up a claim and he had his adjuster call me the next day. The adjuster first stated that I had a $2500 deductable and that I needed to provide either pictures or receipts for the tv's....I had neither of these. He then proceeded to tell me that we could go through the claim process if I choose but it would be a waste of time because since the tv's were both 2 years old the adjusted value plus the repair of the door would come around to the $2500 ded amount. So i bit the bullet and didn't proceed with filling out the large claim packet that he gave me.

Not quite three months later, again in the morning hours the house was broken into again, and the thieves entered through the same door, which had been fixed, but they busted open again! This time they literally went through the entire house, emptying drawers, flipping over mattress's....literally just casing the whole place. Again I called the police and filed a report, then called my agent who had the adjuster call me. I informed the adjuster that although they went through everything in my home the two items that were missing this time was a DVD camcorder and a small fire-proof safe that included a very large childhood collection of old baseball and football cards and a few pieces of jewerly. I estimate that conservatively the safe had $5000 of valuables in it. The adjuster again came back with again "do you have receipts or pictures"....to in total disgust I admitted that no I did not.

Now shame on me for not taking pictures of everthing in my entire house after the first break-in. Because of this the claims agent again told me that this is a separate occurence and the $2500 deductable would have to be exceeded on the contents taken during this second break-in to validate a claim. Because I had no proof of owning these items, and based on my conversations with the adjuster, I very disgustly did not proceed with a claim on this second occurence either.

Fast forward to this past week where I found out that these two "zero dollar claims" on my property are now showing up on the database that all property and casualty companies use to quote coverage. Several agents from various companies have told me that I will be unable to evaluate a different insurance carrier on this property for like 2-3 years or something until I am through this window.

How can this show up on my "claim record" if I didn't proceed through the claim process?? I feel frustrated here on so many levels! Not only did I lose in total 8k plus of my property but now I am being black-balled in from my carrier when they didn't pay a nickel and I didn't even file either claim.

I have also found out this month that one of the construction workers that was at my property during renovations I had done a few months prior to the first break-in was arrested for several theft charges only weeks after the second break-in occurred at my property. This individual is now in a state pen for the next two years. I obviously can't prove anything other than he was in my house, however I am wondering if I should go to the authorities anyway.

You guys are the experts with Home Insurance so I thought I would start here for help. I appreciate any knowledge or thoughts you could share on any of the above. Thank you.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately my home was broken into TWICE within a 90 day time period late last year.

The first occurence happened between 8 & 10 am, it was discovered by my cleaning lady around 11am, and she immediately called me and the police. I left the office and came to the house to meet the officer and had the report filed. The only two items that were taken were 2 lcd flatscreen tv's, but there was also a decent amount of damage to the back-door of my home which they apparently used a crow-bar to enter. I called my agent who opened up a claim and he had his adjuster call me the next day. The adjuster first stated that I had a $2500 deductable and that I needed to provide either pictures or receipts for the tv's....I had neither of these. He then proceeded to tell me that we could go through the claim process if I choose but it would be a waste of time because since the tv's were both 2 years old the adjusted value plus the repair of the door would come around to the $2500 ded amount. So i bit the bullet and didn't proceed with filling out the large claim packet that he gave me.

Not quite three months later, again in the morning hours the house was broken into again, and the thieves entered through the same door, which had been fixed, but they busted open again! This time they literally went through the entire house, emptying drawers, flipping over mattress's....literally just casing the whole place. Again I called the police and filed a report, then called my agent who had the adjuster call me. I informed the adjuster that although they went through everything in my home the two items that were missing this time was a DVD camcorder and a small fire-proof safe that included a very large childhood collection of old baseball and football cards and a few pieces of jewerly. I estimate that conservatively the safe had $5000 of valuables in it. The adjuster again came back with again "do you have receipts or pictures"....to in total disgust I admitted that no I did not.

Now shame on me for not taking pictures of everthing in my entire house after the first break-in. Because of this the claims agent again told me that this is a separate occurence and the $2500 deductable would have to be exceeded on the contents taken during this second break-in to validate a claim. Because I had no proof of owning these items, and based on my conversations with the adjuster, I very disgustly did not proceed with a claim on this second occurence either.

Fast forward to this past week where I found out that these two "zero dollar claims" on my property are now showing up on the database that all property and casualty companies use to quote coverage. Several agents from various companies have told me that I will be unable to evaluate a different insurance carrier on this property for like 2-3 years or something until I am through this window.

How can this show up on my "claim record" if I didn't proceed through the claim process?? I feel frustrated here on so many levels! Not only did I lose in total 8k plus of my property but now I am being black-balled in from my carrier when they didn't pay a nickel and I didn't even file either claim.

I have also found out this month that one of the construction workers that was at my property during renovations I had done a few months prior to the first break-in was arrested for several theft charges only weeks after the second break-in occurred at my property. This individual is now in a state pen for the next two years. I obviously can't prove anything other than he was in my house, however I am wondering if I should go to the authorities anyway.

You guys are the experts with Home Insurance so I thought I would start here for help. I appreciate any knowledge or thoughts you could share on any of the above. Thank you.

Different companies treat claims differently. You do have the claims on there, and partially the reason would be to keep a record for risk management purposes. You DID have 2 break-ins in a 90 day period, that's pretty serious to be honest and would be something underwriting would want to know. That's why some companies (IMO) list claims even if nothing is paid out. And they still pay the adjuster for inspection and whatnot. You filed a claim regardless. The claim just had a zero dollar pay-out.

Contact the insurance agency HQ and ask if they can remove them, that is the best you can do. I doubt it'll do anything though.

If you want to go the police, there is nothing to stop you from doing it. I doubt it'll help with the claims unless it's proven he stole the stuff but then it's really up to the insurance company to cover it, and yada yada. Focus on seeing if the guy confesses first and then contact your agent and adjuster from there.

EDIT: I forgot to put this part in but RBA addressed it. Sometimes claims won't count if they are zero-paid claims, depending on the companies or even the state. So shop around.
 
Last edited:
some companies will not count the zero claims, so you will need to call around or call a IA to get quotes for you.

Secondly......Why in the hell do you have a $2500 deductible? In my area, the savings for you between 1000 and 2500 is maybe 150 bucks, NOT WORTH IT!
 
Next time, keep fighting the claim, especially if it was substantial. The agent should be guiding you. You can make a "statement under oath". If the insurance company isn't going to comply, you can complain to the DOI.
 
Back
Top