Change We Can Believe In....

G.Gordon

Guru
1000 Post Club
3,182
Missouri
The medicare drug benefit is a huge help for millions of seniors. There are the critics of the program, but prior to 1/1/2006 seniors paid for drug cost 100% out of pocket unless they were on medicaid in addition to medicare.

The biggest complaint of Medicare part D has been the coverage gap. This year each medicare beneficiary enrolled in part D has $2830 in drug coverage before they hit the gap. Then they have to pay 100% of the drug cost until they have $4550 out-of-pocket. For most seniors hitting the donut hole this out-of-pocket limit is rarely reached before the whole process is started over Jan. 1 of each year.

One big selling point of the bill passed Sunday touted elimination or reduction of the gap that hurts seniors. Well they delivered.... $250 for seniors reaching the gap. $250 thrown at a $4550 problem... that's nice. That equals about a 5.5% reduction in the out of pocket portion of the GAP... big deal. For seniors reaching the gap that won't be realized as much help when some of the more expensive medications can cost $250 for one month's supply.

What would have helped more? Drug price control. Medicare has fixed prices for everything a medicare beneficiary gets medically... except drugs. The market is free to charge what they will. I blame the last administration as well as this one for being chickens when they needed to control big pharma. One simple regulation setting the price of every drug prescribed to a medicare beneficiary to the price they are sold at in Cananda would have saved seniors more than $250 this year and saved Medicare billions. There is no reason a drug can be sold for $220 here and you can order the same drug from Canada for $85 and it is made in the USA.
 
$250 for seniors reaching the gap. $250 thrown at a $4550 problem... that's nice. That equals about a 5.5% reduction in the out of pocket portion of the GAP... big deal. For seniors reaching the gap that won't be realized as much help when some of the more expensive medications can cost $250 for one month's supply.

My understanding is that the "Reconciliation Bill" closes the doughnut hole totally by 2020.

What would have helped more? Drug price control.

More control (especially by the federal government) is never the answer. Where does it stop? There's a much better free-market solution...

There is no reason a drug can be sold for $220 here and you can order the same drug from Canada for $85 and it is made in the USA.

Bingo. Allow re-importation. Works better than more "controls" ever could.
 
By 2020... WTF good is that? 9.5 years away? Do exactly to drug prices what they do for a standard x-ray... set a price. Not a new concept when thinking about Medicare.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
There is no need to re-importation. If they can make it here and sell it there for a price it stands to reason they are making money. If they can do that.... they have to see it here for that price.
 
Last edited:
There is no need to re-importation. If they can make it here and sell it there for a price it stands to reason they are making money. If they can do that.... they have to see it here for that price.

Regulating anybody's prices and profits is very, very dangerous. That's what they do in Communism. Where does it stop?
 
I understand, but they are already doing it with Medicare beneficiaries' healthcare.

But it hasn't driven cost down much, has it?

Here's a good idea championed by Rep. Paul Ryan of Wisconsin...

Stop Medicare - disband it. Of course you can't cut the water of seniors that have come to rely upon it, so give them a voucher to pay for coverage. Let 'em shop for it on their own in the free, competitive market, and buy the benefits that are important to them. Customized - not standardized, one-size-fits-all.

Of course, those in charge of the nanny state don't think they're capable of making good choices - they know better. I disagree, all you 've got to do is look at history.

Wouldn't there be abuses? Of course there will, just as there are now.

Unleashing the competitive power of the free market will drive down costs and improve quality faster (as it has with just about every other product or service) than any sort of "government control" ever will!
 
Negotiating drug prices with big pharma appears to work very well for the Department of Veterans Affairs; however, congress bowed to the wishes of the last administration and disallowed Medicare from negotiating drug prices. Another example of Bushwhacking.
 
Back
Top