- 4,716
Carriers DEMANDED the mandate/penalty in 2008-2009. In 2015, they whined that it wasn't working. The healthier people were/are still not signing up.
"This market" is DOA. Good riddance. Bring back underwriting, and allow those who are not accepted by any insurer, to buy into Medicare. Dead Broke? Medicaid for you.
It's Free market, with Government safety nets for those who aren't accepted by the Free Market system. Simple stuff.
Your plan is almost complete. You forgot about those that have an obamacare plan and live in a State that did not expand Medicaid. I say we keep obamacare just for those people as a fail-safe safety net but only after you've been turned away from all the others.