Bad analogy..........sorry if I offended my friends on the board.
But, I will say, the situation came up today. Long term client and good friend, buying off exchange in Sarasota county. Choice of county specific HMO and for $50/mo more, the MC PPO HSA. As you know, Children's hospital not in network in the HMO, but is in the MC network. His daughter spent a week in childrens hospital last year, and told him I can't be part of the HMO sale. He got the idea and is spending the extra $50 for the MC.
It's all situational, no blanket statements or advice, as we all know.
On exchange, the only choice is the HMO
That analogy wasn't your finest hour
Anyone taking the Aetna HMO with children or cancer concerns has to be out of their minds, the MC plan is the better choice, particularly since Aetna finally admitted to me today that there are no referrals needed for the MC even though the SBC says they are.