Depends on the age with the comparisons I've done recently. Quoted today - 65 y/o non smoke female and the difference in G and F in Georgia was only $23 a month - add in the $183 and they would have only saved $93 a year . . . She is taking the F . . .
Thanks for proving my point. Even with that scenario, Plan G saves the client $93. In the greater metro Atlanta area, the lowest cost Plan F for a female age 65 non-tobacco user is $137.70. The lowest cost Plan G is $110.66 (these rates exclude any potential discounts). That's $27.04 per month or $324.48 per year. So obviously you aren't quoting the lowest premium plans.
I challenge you to ask EVERY potential Med Supp client the following question:
Mrs. Client, do you see a reason why you should pay the insurance company an extra $324.48 so that they will pay the $183 deductible for you?
I can guarantee you aren't stressing the savings to these clients. If anything, you are making Plan F out to be the best plan. I've found over many years of selling that when you educate a client, they make much better decisions. But you are interested in educating the client. Hell, you aren't interested in educating yourself.