I would, unless I'm missing something they wouldn't legally be able to cancel my renewals. Again, this hypothetical situation would rarely if ever occur. If I'm not writing my client at one of the best level rates to begin with I'm doing a disservice.
I suppose that I would consider replacing someone level if they truly stopped smoking and now qualify for a NS rate, but again I don't see that happening very often.
Replacing a GI, graded or modified is most common.
Most companies will reduce the premium on an existing policy to a non smoking rate upon proof the person has not smoked for a period of time so there is no real reason to replace for that reason.
Last edited: