The reason for my post is this: I feel like I should be making more money for how many sales I have.
Of course you do, but you did nothing on the front end to get those people on your phone line. You can feel that way, but you shouldn't. The company brought you in, trained you, and fronted every dollar for YOU to make those sales. Every call center agent who is a top producer thinks they deserve more. I certainly did when I started out in a small agency. You're currently doing the easy part. Getting those people to talk to is the difficult part.
When you put it all on the line, and acquire those clients on your own, then yes, you deserve more. Currently your low risk is giving you low pay. That's the way it goes. But as Todd said, it's not nearly as easy as it seems. Keep in mind that company that you work for might not see a profit on your sales until year 2, or perhaps even year 3 depending on their expenses. If you want to go on your own at some point (I'm all for it, but you REALLY have to want it and be prepared to sacrifice) then I agree with KGMOMMA, get yourself in a safe position financially first and be prepared to dig deep.
The upside is, if you can get to a point where you are consistently gathering say, 20 Med supp clients a month, you can look up in 5 years and be very well off. But in the real world of business you get compensated based on the value you bring to the business and marketplace. So never stop increasing your marketing, sales, and business skills and applying them and your value will also increase. Hence, more $$$$$.