Apparently you missed the part where I stated time will tell. As stated earlier, final expense is priced at a loss for years, then the numbers begin to work out. How many FE companies have dropped out? Foremost, Shenandoah, Forethought....
How many companies have made rate increases, commission changes and underwriting/app changes?
Think they were all profiting like mad and that is why they left or made changes?
Oxford may be right, may be wrong, time will tell as stated earlier. Just playing devils advocate to some questionable posts like Gordon:
Oxford has tighter UW, a very time consuming POS interview and they cut renewals in half.
Original Street was Yr 1- 105%, Yrs2-10 - 7%, Yrs 11+- 1%
New Street Yr 1- 120%, Yrs2-5 - 5%, Yrs 6-10 - 2%
15% increase in year 1, 29% increase 2-5, 72% increase 6-10
Depending on persistency, it takes until year 9 or 10 to start seeing lesser pay on the new scale than the old. Is this good or bad? Depends on the agent, just like to have facts out rather than false assumptions or half information.
I'm not getting your numbers here; they just don't add up correctly.
If you take the old contract at 105% 1st year, years 2-10 @7% (70%), that all adds up to 175% over 10 years.
120% 1st year, years 2-5 @5% (20%), and years 6-10 @2% (10%), that adds up to 150%.
So, over 10 years the agent is making 20% less, but they are making 15% more the 1st year...woohooo!