I am looking for organic traffic results, not pay per click. I believe I only received 3 quote requests in 2012, but closed 4 policies. Since that is terribly low traffic, but a fantastic closing ratio I am thinking of investing in a professional site in 2013 and would like to hear about what kind of results I can look forward to. If you wouldn't mind mentioning if you spend a lot of time on seo that would also be helpful.
You should invest. It works. Every day. Forever. Make your site look good. And hire an SEO firm to get your site seen.